Stillwater Movie Critique: A Mess The place the Action, Suspense & Ending Totally Are unsuccessful

Matt Damon stars in Tom McCarthy’s Stillwater. Jessica Forde / Emphasis Attributes

Contemplating its impeccable credentials, I find myself doubly disappointed in the eagerly awaited but flawed new film Stillwater for the reason that (1) I anticipated so substantially more from director Tom McCarthy, who won an Oscar for the excellent, unforgettable Highlight, (2) it stars the always responsible Matt Damon, and (3) it is smart sufficient that it ought to be better.

Based mostly on the harrowing story of Amanda Knox, the American pupil in Italy who was falsely accused and convicted in 2007 of killing her roommate (and later exonerated), Stillwater performs unfastened with the points of the situation and shifts the narrative concentration to the girl’s father. It took Mr. McCarthy and a few co-writers to dilute the headlines and distill the scandal into a dull, unwieldy screenplay crowded with irrelevant specifics. The alleged American killer, who protests her innocence, is now a girl from Stillwater, Oklahoma, named Allison, played by a massively miscast Abigail Breslin, who has outgrown each whisper of the appeal she as soon as shown in Tiny Skip Sunshine. But the aim is not on Allison, but on her extended-suffering father Bill.


STILLWATER ★★1/2
(2.5/4 stars)
Directed by: Tom McCarthy
Created by: Tom McCarthy, Marcus Hinchey, Thomas Bidegain, Noé Debré
Starring: Matt Damon, Camille Cottin, Abigail Breslin
Functioning time: 140 mins.


Closely researched by a promptly maturing Matt Damon, replete with beer intestine and graying hair, Invoice Baker is an unemployed oil rig driller with ample complications of his individual to fill a dozen cleaning soap operas from the American dustbowl: a tattooed roughneck whose wife dedicated suicide, and a recovering alcoholic and previous drug addict who couldn’t vote for Trump for the reason that he’s also a convicted felon. He feels factors, but as an uneducated, usually compromised American male, he does not clearly show his inner thoughts or articulate them coherently. It is quick to see why he travels back again and forth from Stillwater to Marseille to assist his estranged daughter, innocently imprisoned in a French jail for murdering her girlfriend. Or so he thinks.

It will take approximately the duration of the film’s runtime for Monthly bill to find out the correct facts of a circumstance the French authorities refuse to re-open, and in the interim, director McCarthy crowds a substantial surfeit of content into a quite smaller plot, when Invoice sweats and strains to come across the boy who was the only witness to what truly occurred at the criminal offense scene. Unable to communicate French and turned down by everyone to whom he appeals for assist, Bill shifts gears and moves to Marseille the place he supports himself with random construction jobs and falls in love with Virginie (played by Camille Cottin), a French actress and solitary mother, and gets to be the surrogate dad to her 9-yr-old daughter. Alongside the way Stillwater turns into a domestic drama that starts to really feel annoyingly contrived. It is not a film in which all of the fragments in good shape comfortably, and the ending, set again in Oklahoma, is a complete catastrophe.

Stillwater is a structural mess, but to be good, it has times of keenly noticed honesty, and the actors are absolutely believable. But its makes an attempt to have interaction the viewer’s feelings are compelled and ineffectual. It would have served the factual material in the Amanda Knox case better if the script experienced simply informed the story as the secret evolved as an alternative of padding it from a fictional character’s level of view. We once in a while empathize with Bill’s affections for the women about him (he does not like any of the adult males), for the reason that McCarthy states we ought to, but he presents no evidence of why we need to. With minimal action, no suspense and an ending that fails in each individual way, Matt Damon is the only point unforgettable about Stillwater.


Observer Evaluations are normal assessments of new and noteworthy cinema.

‘Stillwater’ Is a Mess of a Movie Where the Action, Suspense and Ending Utterly Fail

Leave your vote

Related Articles

Back to top button

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.